Competition · 7 min

Difficulty vs. Execution: The Score Sheet Trade-Off Every All-Star Coach Faces

Coach Jason Tiede · November 2026

Every all-star coach has had this argument, with their staff or just with themselves. Do we keep the harder skill and hope it hits, or pull it back and clean what we have? The athletes want the big skills. Parents want the big skills. And the score sheet keeps quietly telling you something else.

This is one of the most important calls you make in a season, and most programs make it on gut feeling. Here's a better way to make it.

How the Trade-Off Works

All-star score sheets generally separate what you do (difficulty) from how well you do it (execution), across categories like standing tumbling, running tumbling, stunts, pyramids, tosses, and jumps. The details change by level, division, and event producer, so read the current score sheet you'll actually be judged on. But the logic is consistent: difficulty sets your ceiling, execution decides how close you get to it, and deductions take points away from whatever's left.

I broke down the categories and deduction risks in score sheet strategy: execution points and deductions. This post is about the decision that comes after you understand the sheet: what to put in the routine.

Difficulty you can't hit isn't difficulty. It's a deduction you scheduled in advance. The routine that wins is the hardest routine your team can hit on its worst day, not its best.

Meet Cascade All Stars Royals

Let's use a hypothetical team. Cascade All Stars "Royals" is a Level 4 senior team with 22 athletes. The coaches built the routine aggressively in the summer: a full standing tumbling section with everyone throwing the top skill, an elite stunt sequence, a pyramid with a tough transition, and a running tumbling section that maxes out the level.

Now it's November. Here's what practice shows:

The head coach wants to keep everything. An assistant wants to pull back. Both have a point. So how do you decide?

A Framework for the Decision

1. Measure, Don't Guess

Start with real hit rates. Not "she usually gets it," but actual numbers across full-outs. For two weeks, Royals tracked every attempt on every questionable skill, in the routine, at full-out energy.

That alone settles a lot of arguments. Skills that "usually hit" in drills often look very different in a full-out with fatigue and music.

Track the misses, too. A standing tuck that lands short with a hand down tells you something different than one that never leaves the ground. A stunt that wobbles but stays up is a different problem than one that comes down. Write down what each miss looked like, not just that it happened.

2. Ask What the Skill Is Actually Worth

A harder skill only matters if it changes your score. Depending on how your score sheet counts difficulty, a few athletes throwing a harder skill may not move the needle much, while a falling athlete hurts both execution and deductions.

For each questionable skill, ask:

3. Set a Hit-Rate Line

Before competition season, decide as a staff what hit rate a skill needs to stay in the routine. Make the call based on data, not emotion, and set a date to review it. Agreeing on the line in advance takes the personal side out of the decision when it's time to pull a skill.

4. Build in a Backup

The best routines have a plan B built into the choreography. For Royals, the standing tumbling athletes who aren't consistent get a backup skill that fits the same counts and the same visual. The struggling stunt group gets an alternate sequence that hits on the same music.

If the skill comes around, you swap back. If it doesn't, nobody has to relearn the routine the week of competition.

5. Think in Seasons, Not Weekends

Early-season competitions are a chance to test. Some programs keep a harder skill in at the first event to see how it performs under pressure, then decide. That can work, as long as you're honest about the results and not just hoping.

By the time bids and the biggest events are on the line, the routine should be built around what your team hits.

Where Execution Points Hide

Pulling a skill back isn't giving up points. It's moving them. When athletes aren't fighting to survive a skill, they have energy for everything else that earns execution: tighter motions, better jump height, sharper transitions, cleaner landings, synchronization, and performance.

For Royals, cleaning the pyramid transition and simplifying one stunt group's sequence did more than prevent falls. It freed up practice time that went straight into jumps and standing tumbling technique, which lifted execution across the board.

If you want a broader look at structure, I wrote about how to build a routine that wins from the first eight-count to the last pose.

Talking to Athletes and Parents

This is often the hardest part. Pulling a skill feels personal to an athlete who's been working toward it. Be direct:

Athletes respect honesty, and parents respect a plan.

What Changed for Royals

After two weeks of tracking, Royals kept the top standing skill for most of the team and gave a backup to the rest. They kept the elite stunt sequence for four groups and built an alternate for the fifth. They simplified one count in the pyramid transition to fix timing. Difficulty stayed competitive. Execution went up. And the routine stopped depending on everything going right.

How JMT Helps With the Trade-Off

This is the kind of decision I work through with programs every season. The JMT Score Sheet Breakdown walks your staff through how difficulty, execution, and deductions are scored, so you can make these calls with confidence. And JMT All Star Choreography is designed around the score sheet from the start, with backup options built into the counts and a clean-up session included to tighten execution once your team has the routine.

I've been on both sides of this: as an all-star national champion athlete who competed on the World Finals floor, and as a coach who has taken teams to Worlds and Summit. The teams that win aren't always the ones with the hardest routines. They're the ones with the hardest routines they can actually hit.

If you want a routine built around your team's real numbers, let's talk. Booking and quote details are on the checkout page.

Book your routine