The routine looked great in August. Now it's November, two athletes have quit, a flyer is out with a wrist injury, and the running tumbling section that was supposed to be your strength is hitting about half the time. You're asking the question every all-star coach asks at some point: do we keep pushing, or do we change the routine?
There's no shame in either answer. But there is a wrong way to decide, and it usually involves waiting too long. Here's how to make the call with your head instead of your hope.
Why Midseason Changes Happen
Choreography is built around a roster and a skill set at a moment in time. Both of those move. Over a season, you'll see some combination of:
- Roster changes. Athletes quit, move, get hurt, or get moved to another team.
- Skills that didn't arrive. The standing tuck you planned on for five athletes is still "almost" for three of them.
- Skills that arrived early. A stunt group is ready for harder skills than the routine gives them, and you're leaving difficulty on the table.
- Score feedback. Your first competition score sheet shows exactly where you're bleeding points.
- Rule or division changes. A team moves divisions, or a skill isn't legal the way you thought under current USASF rules.
Any of these can justify a change. None of them automatically means you need a full restructure.
A Real Scenario: Ironclad Athletics Steel
Let's use a hypothetical team. Ironclad Athletics Steel is a Level 3 junior team with 22 athletes, chasing a D2 Summit bid. Here's November:
- One flyer is out for six to eight weeks.
- Two athletes left the program, so a back-spot and a base are gone.
- The running tumbling section has eight athletes on a round-off back handspring tuck. Five land it clean. Three are inconsistent.
- First competition scores showed solid difficulty but low execution in stunts and pyramid, with a building deduction from a fall.
- The dance section scored fine.
The owner's instinct is to bring the choreographer back and redo everything. The head coach wants to just keep drilling. Both instincts are wrong in different ways.
The Three Levels of Change
I think about midseason changes in three tiers. Picking the right one saves time, saves your athletes' confidence, and saves points.
Level 1: Tweak
Small swaps inside the existing structure. Replace a skill an athlete can't hit with one they can. Swap an athlete's position in a formation. Adjust a count so a transition has room to breathe.
Use a tweak when the routine's bones are good and the problem is one or two athletes or one or two counts. Most midseason fixes live here.
For Steel, the three inconsistent tumblers are a tweak. Move them to a clean back handspring or a well-placed jump, or reposition them in the formation so the strongest tumblers sit where judges look first. That's an afternoon of work, not a rebuild.
Level 2: Section Rebuild
Pull out one section and rechoreograph it while keeping everything around it. This is the right call when one section is structurally broken: a stunt sequence built around a group that no longer exists, or a pyramid that depends on a flyer who's out.
For Steel, losing a flyer, a base, and a back-spot means at least one stunt group is gone. The stunt section and probably the pyramid need to be rebuilt around the groups you actually have. Trying to patch it with alternates who aren't ready is how you end up with another building deduction.
Level 3: Full Restructure
New formations, new sequencing, new section order. This is a big lift, and it's rarely the right move midseason. But sometimes it is:
- The roster has changed so much the routine no longer fits.
- The team moved levels or divisions.
- The routine was built around skills that are never going to arrive this season.
If you're considering a full restructure, be honest about how many practices you have before your next important event. A brand-new routine your athletes don't own yet often scores worse than a modified one they can hit in their sleep.
How to Decide: Questions to Ask
Before you change anything, answer these with your staff:
- What does the score sheet say? Look at where you're actually losing points. If you need a refresher, I covered execution points and deductions in detail. Fix the biggest point losses first.
- Is this a skill problem or a structure problem? If athletes can hit the skill in isolation but not in the routine, the problem may be a transition or fatigue, not the skill itself. Choreography can fix that.
- How many practices until the next event that matters? Two weeks out from a bid event is not the time for a full restructure.
- Who's coming back, and when? An injured flyer back in three weeks is a different plan than one out for the season.
- Can the team learn it and clean it in time? Learning a section is fast. Cleaning it to competition standard isn't.
A routine is a promise you made to the score sheet in August. By November, your roster may not be able to keep it. Changing the choreography isn't admitting failure. It's making a promise your team can actually keep.
Making Changes Without Losing the Team
Midseason changes are as much a culture moment as a choreography one. Athletes notice when their part changes, and parents notice faster. A few things I've learned:
- Frame changes around points, not people. "We're moving this section so it scores higher" lands better than "you're coming out of the tumbling pass."
- Change once, not five times. Make a decision and commit. Constant small edits wear athletes out and make the routine feel unstable.
- Keep what works. Steel's dance section scored fine. Don't touch it. Familiar sections give athletes something solid to lean on while they learn the new parts.
- Rep the transitions. New sections break at the seams. Drill the eight-count going in and coming out, not just the new material.
- Put the music back together. If counts change, the mix may need to change too. Don't let a stunt sequence fight the music.
The Plan for Steel
Here's what I'd actually do with this team:
- Tweak the running tumbling for the three inconsistent athletes now.
- Rebuild the stunt section and pyramid around the remaining groups, with legal skills the team can hit at a high rate.
- Leave the dance, jumps, and opening alone.
- Plan a second tweak for when the flyer returns, so she can step back into a defined role without disrupting what the team has cleaned.
- Track hit rates on the rebuilt sections every practice for three weeks before the next competition.
That's a section rebuild with a planned follow-up, not a full restructure. The team keeps most of what it knows, and the parts that were costing points get fixed.
When to Bring in a Choreographer
Some tweaks your staff can handle. A section rebuild usually needs the person who understands how the whole routine fits together: counts, flow, formations, and how the rebuilt section reads to a judge. That's choreography work.
JMT All Star Choreography is a full competition routine designed around the score sheet, built from Worlds and Summit-level experience, with a clean-up session included. For teams that need a midseason rebuild, we work from your current roster, your current skills, and your score sheet, so the changes land where the points are. If you want the bigger picture on what a winning routine is built on, start there.
I've been doing this for 20+ years, from the competition floor to growing a program from 4 teams to 12. Midseason changes are part of the job. The programs that handle them well are the ones that decide early and commit.
Pricing depends on the scope of the changes. Reach out with your roster, your level, and your next event date.