Program Building · 7 min

Coaching Your Coaches: Using Monthly Scorecards to Develop Your Staff

Coach Jason Tiede · November 2026

Most gym owners are great at developing athletes and terrible at developing coaches. Not because they don't care, but because nobody ever taught them how. Coaches get hired, handed a team, and left to figure it out. Then the owner wonders why three teams are thriving and two are stuck.

If your program is going to grow, your staff has to grow with it. One of the simplest tools for that is something many programs already use for teams: the monthly scorecard.

Why Staff Development Gets Skipped

In a busy gym, staff development is always the thing that can wait. There's choreography to finish, a competition to prep, parents to call, and classes to cover. Coaches get feedback when something goes wrong, not on a regular rhythm.

That creates a few predictable problems:

You can't scale a cheer program on the owner's eyes alone. At some point your coaches have to see what you see. A monthly scorecard is how you teach them to look.

Meet Bayside Cheer Co.

Let's use a hypothetical program. Bayside Cheer Co. is a growing all-star gym with several competitive teams, a rec and prep program, and a staff of head coaches, assistants, and tumbling instructors. The owner is still coaching two teams herself.

The teams she coaches are sharp. The others vary. One coach runs efficient practices but struggles with parent communication. Another builds great culture but loses track of skill progressions. A newer coach is talented but unsure what's expected.

She doesn't need to replace anyone. She needs a system that helps each coach get better on purpose.

What a Staff Scorecard Measures

Earlier in this series, I wrote about using monthly scorecards to grow your program at the team and program level. A staff scorecard applies the same idea to the people running those teams.

Keep it simple. Pick a handful of categories that reflect your program's standards. For Bayside, the categories were:

Practice Quality

Athlete Progress

Routine Readiness

Communication

Growth

Each category gets a simple rating and a short note. The goal isn't a grade. It's a conversation.

How to Run the Monthly Review

Make It Two-Way

Have each coach fill out their own scorecard before the meeting. Then compare it with yours. Gaps between how a coach sees themselves and how you see them are where the real development happens.

Focus on One or Two Things

Don't hand a coach ten things to fix. Pick one strength to keep doing and one or two areas to work on before next month. Small, steady improvement beats a long list nobody follows.

Tie It to Real Outcomes

Connect staff scorecards to team results. If a team's stunt hit rate is dropping, look at practice structure. If a team's parents are frustrated, look at communication. The scorecard helps you find the cause, not just the symptom.

Recognize Wins

Coaches need to hear what's working. A monthly scorecard is a built-in moment to name progress, in front of the coach and sometimes in front of the staff.

Keep the Calendar in Mind

What you focus on should change with the season. In the preseason, weight the scorecard toward practice structure, skill progressions, and team culture. During competition season, shift toward routine readiness, cleaning schedules, and how coaches handle the pressure of a competition weekend. After the season ends, look back at the whole year with each coach and set goals for the next one.

A scorecard that never changes starts to feel like paperwork. One that follows the season feels like coaching.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

What Changed for Bayside

After a few months of staff scorecards, Bayside had shared standards that every coach understood. The coach who struggled with parent communication had a simple weekly update routine. The coach who lost track of progressions had a tracking sheet she actually used. The newer coach knew exactly what was expected and grew into a head coach role.

And the owner? She stepped back from coaching one of her two teams, because she trusted her staff to run it. That freed her time to work on the business. If you're trying to get there, I wrote about how to grow your cheer program without a full-time director.

Building the System Without Burning Out

Staff scorecards take time to set up, and they take discipline to keep running. Many owners start strong and drop the habit by the second month. That's where outside support helps.

I've been a Program Director, including at Cheer Athletics UK, and I grew a program from about 30 athletes on four teams to more than 180 athletes on 12 teams. A big part of that growth was building a staff that could carry the standards without me in every room. Scorecards were a core part of it.

How JMT CEC Supports Your Staff

Competitive Edge Core (CEC) Program Director Support is built for program owners who want this kind of structure without building it alone. The tiers are defined by how much support you need:

Add-ons include staff training, practice plans, leadership coaching, routine reviews, choreo support, and recruiting strategy. Staff training and leadership coaching pair especially well with staff scorecards.

If you're ready to build a staff that grows with your program, take a look at the CEC options and pick the level of support that fits.

See CEC plans