Every program owner has had this conversation. A parent wants their kid on an elite team. The athlete has some of the skills, but not all. The family isn't sure about the travel. And you're trying to fill out rosters on both sides without losing anyone. Where does this team, and this athlete, actually belong?
Choosing between prep and elite isn't just a placement decision. It shapes the routine you build, the season you sell, and whether that family is still in your gym next year. Here's how I think about it.
Prep and Elite Are Different Products
Start here, because a lot of programs get this wrong. Prep is not "elite, but worse." It's a different experience built for different goals.
In general, elite all-star is the full commitment: more practice hours, more competitions, more travel, longer routines, and the chase for bids to events like Worlds and Summit. Prep is typically a lighter commitment, with fewer practices, a shorter season or schedule, more local events, and a routine format that's simpler to run. The exact routine length, divisions, and event options depend on current USASF rules and the event producers you attend, so check those every season.
What prep gives a family:
- A real competitive experience without the full elite time and travel load.
- A place to build skills and confidence before moving up.
- A path for athletes who play other sports or have busy schedules.
What elite gives a family:
- The highest level of competition, training, and commitment.
- A shot at bids and the biggest stages in the sport.
- A team culture built around chasing the top.
If you sell prep as second place, families will feel it. If you sell it as its own track with its own wins, they'll stay.
A Real Scenario: Silver Creek Cheer
Let's use a hypothetical program. Silver Creek Cheer has about 90 athletes. After tryouts, they have enough for three elite teams and a group of roughly 35 athletes who don't neatly fit anywhere. Some are young and new. Some have strong skills but can't commit to the elite schedule. A few are borderline elite but would be at the bottom of an elite roster.
The owner's first instinct is to squeeze as many athletes as possible onto elite teams. More elite teams feel like a stronger program. But a Level 2 elite team with half its athletes missing the required skills won't score, and those families won't love the experience.
The better plan is to build two prep teams and keep the elite teams tight.
How to Decide: Five Questions for Each Team
1. Does the roster have the skills for the level?
Look at what athletes can hit consistently today, not what they might have by March. A team that can't fill the required skill sections at their level is going to struggle on difficulty no matter how good the choreography is. Prep may let that same group compete at a level they can actually execute well.
2. Can the families commit to the schedule?
Elite means more practices, more travel, and more weekends. If half the roster can't commit to that, you'll have attendance problems all season. A team that practices together consistently beats a more skilled team that never has full-outs with everyone there.
3. What do the athletes need right now?
A new athlete with a back walkover and a lot of potential may grow faster on a prep team where she gets reps and confidence than on an elite team where she's hidden in the back. Development isn't a straight line, and prep is often the fastest path to elite.
4. What does your program's pipeline need?
Strong programs think about next year's elite teams this year. Prep teams are where you build them. If every athlete gets pushed to elite too early, your pipeline dries up and your elite rosters get thin.
5. What will keep this family in your gym?
This is the business question. A family that has a good season on a prep team comes back. A family that sits on the bench of an elite team they weren't ready for often doesn't. Placement is also a big part of building team culture that actually performs. Athletes who fit their team show up, work, and stay.
Prep is not the consolation prize. It's a different promise to a different family. When you put a team on the right track and give it a routine built for that track, everybody wins, including your elite teams.
Building the Right Routine for Each Track
Once you've placed a team, the choreography has to match the track. This is where a lot of programs miss.
Elite Routines
Elite choreography is built around the full score sheet at the highest level of difficulty the team can execute cleanly. Every section is maximized: stunt sequences, pyramid transitions, running and standing tumbling, jumps, and dance, all designed to read well to judges and stack points.
Prep Routines
Prep choreography should not be a copy-and-paste of an elite routine with skills taken out. That looks unfinished, and judges can tell. A good prep routine:
- Fits the format. Routine length and sections built for prep, within current USASF level rules.
- Matches the actual skills. Every skill is one the athletes can hit, placed where it reads best.
- Uses formations and transitions to add value. When difficulty is limited, clean transitions, sharp motions, and good spacing do a lot of work on the score sheet.
- Is age-appropriate. Music, motions, and dance choices that fit the athletes.
- Leaves room to grow. Skill slots that can be upgraded midseason as athletes progress.
I went deeper on building competitive, USASF-legal prep routines earlier in the series.
Silver Creek's Plan
Here's how I'd set up Silver Creek:
- Three tight elite teams, each roster built around athletes who can hit the level and commit to the schedule.
- Two prep teams, split by age and skill, each with its own routine built for prep.
- Clear upgrade paths. Prep athletes know what skills move them toward elite. Coaches track those skills and review placement midseason or at next tryouts.
- Honest communication with families. Explain the difference in time, travel, and goals, and frame prep as a real option, not a fallback.
The result: elite teams that can actually score at their level, prep teams that have a great season, and a pipeline that feeds next year's elite rosters.
Common Mistakes
- Putting too many athletes on elite. It looks good on the website and costs you points and families.
- Treating prep as an afterthought. Prep teams get less staff attention, worse practice times, and recycled choreography. Families notice.
- Not explaining the difference. If parents don't understand what prep is, they'll assume it's a demotion.
- Building the routine before placement is final. Choreography should be designed around the roster you actually have.
Where JMT Fits
JMT Prep Choreography is built for the track, not borrowed from it. Every routine is age-appropriate, matched to the team's actual skill level, designed within current USASF level rules, and includes music sync. The goal is a routine that lets a prep team compete with confidence and leaves room for athletes to grow.
I've spent 20+ years in this sport, coached more than 1,000 athletes, and grew a program from about 30 athletes on 4 teams to 180+ on 12. Prep teams were a big part of that growth. They're where future elite athletes are built and where families decide to stay.
Pricing depends on the team and the scope. Send your roster, level, and season goals and we'll talk it through.