You've got a senior with a standing full sitting next to a freshman who just learned a back walkover. Three athletes came from an all-star gym. Six have never stunted before this year. And you need one competition routine that scores, plus sideline material the whole squad can perform on Friday night.
That's the reality of school cheer. You don't get to try out your way to a perfectly even roster. Here's how to choreograph a routine that makes a wide skill range work for you instead of against you.
Why School Rosters Look Like This
All-star teams are built by level. School teams are built by who walks in the door. On any given high school squad you might have:
- Former all-star athletes with advanced tumbling and stunting.
- Gymnasts or dancers with strong body control but little cheer experience.
- Athletes from other sports who are strong and coachable but brand new.
- Returning athletes who have grown steadily through the program.
You also have a schedule all-star coaches don't: game day, pep rallies, school events, and academics. Practice time is limited, and the same athletes have to cover sideline and competition.
That's the job. The choreography has to be built for it.
A Real Scenario: Oak Hollow High School
Let's use a hypothetical squad. Oak Hollow High School has 18 athletes on its competition team:
- Tumbling: Four athletes with standing and running back tucks or better, two with a full. Six with a back handspring. Eight with a round-off or less.
- Stunting: Two experienced stunt groups that can hit extended skills and more advanced dismounts. Two newer groups solid at prep level.
- Jumps: Mixed. A handful of athletes have great height and technique. Most are still developing.
- Dance: A strong group of dancers who can carry a section, and several athletes who need simpler movement.
The coach's worry: "If I build for my top athletes, half the team is standing around. If I build for my newer athletes, I'm leaving difficulty on the table."
Both are real risks. The answer is layering.
The Layering Approach
Instead of choreographing one skill for everyone, build each section in layers so every athlete is doing something purposeful and the strongest skills are featured where judges look.
Tumbling: Feature, Support, Frame
- Feature: Put your strongest tumblers in clean, visible passes. Two strong, legal passes landed in a clear lane read better than eight mixed passes all happening at once.
- Support: Athletes with back handsprings perform in synchronized groups. Matching skills in unison looks sharp and scores on execution.
- Frame: Newer athletes perform jumps, motions, or a simple skill that frames the featured pass. They're part of the picture, not hidden behind it.
The key is that nothing looks like filler. Every athlete is on count, in formation, with a purpose.
Stunts: Match Groups to Skills
Don't make every group do the same stunt sequence if two groups can't hit it. Build the sequence so experienced groups take harder skills while newer groups hit a clean, legal skill on the same count.
Done well, this reads as intentional. Judges see contrast and control, not a team falling apart. Done poorly, it looks like half the groups didn't get the skill. The difference is timing and formation: matched counts, clean transitions, and groups placed so the eye goes to the strongest skill first.
Pyramid: Build Around Your Anchors
Your experienced stunters are the anchors. Build the pyramid structure around them and connect newer groups in roles they can hit every time. A clean, simple pyramid with good transitions often scores better than an ambitious one that falls once in three runs.
Jumps and Dance: Unify the Team
These are the sections where everyone can shine together. Sharp jumps in unison and a dance section with clean motions and strong facials make the whole team look like one unit. Give your dancers a moment to stand out, but keep the core of the section achievable for everyone.
A wide skill range isn't a weakness to hide. It's a design problem to solve. Put every athlete where she makes the routine better, and the judges see a team, not a talent gap.
Compliance Comes First
School cheer runs under different rules than all-star. Your state association (for example, MSHAA in Missouri) and NFHS spirit rules set what's legal, and those rules apply to every athlete in the routine, not just the advanced ones. A skill your former all-star athlete does every day at her gym may not be legal in a school routine.
Before choreography starts, confirm what's allowed this season for your state and division. Build every layer inside those limits. A deduction for an illegal skill wipes out the points that skill was supposed to earn.
Building for Growth During the Season
School teams improve a lot between the first practice and the last competition. Build the routine so it can grow:
- Upgrade slots. Mark spots where a back handspring can become a tuck, or a prep-level stunt can become extended, when athletes are ready and it's legal.
- Swap-ready positions. Know which athletes can step into a featured role if someone gets hurt or has a conflict.
- Midseason check-ins. Look at your first competition results and decide what to upgrade before the next one.
Don't Forget the Opening
Judges form an impression fast. The first eight-counts set the tone for the whole routine. For a team with a wide skill range, open with your strongest unified moment: a clean motion sequence, a synchronized jump, or a featured pass framed by the whole team. I wrote more about what judges notice in the first 30 seconds, and it applies doubly when your roster is mixed.
Sideline and Game Day
Your competition routine isn't the only choreography your team needs. Sideline cheers, chants, and game-day routines should be performable by the whole squad, loud, sharp, and crowd-focused. They're also a great place to build confidence for newer athletes, who get reps in front of a crowd every week. Good sideline work makes your competition team better.
The Plan for Oak Hollow
Here's what I'd build:
- An opening featuring the two strongest tumblers in a clean lane, framed by a synchronized jump from the whole team.
- A stunt sequence where the two experienced groups hit advanced skills while the two newer groups hit clean prep-level skills on the same counts.
- A pyramid anchored by experienced groups, with simpler, high-percentage roles for newer athletes.
- A standing tumbling section split into synchronized groups by skill.
- A dance section that features the strong dancers and keeps everyone sharp and together.
- Marked upgrade slots for midseason, all inside current state and NFHS rules.
That's a routine where every athlete has a job, the best skills are visible, and nothing looks like filler.
If you want the broader picture on school competition routines that score, start with that post.
How JMT Builds School Routines
JMT School Choreography delivers MSHAA-compliant competitive routines plus sideline and game-day routines, built for the roster you actually have. I've spent 20+ years in the sport, coached more than 1,000 athletes, and built routines for teams at every level. Wide skill ranges are one of my favorite problems to solve, because when the layering works, the whole squad looks like a championship team.
Pricing depends on the routine type and scope. Send your roster, skill breakdown, and competition schedule and I'll put together a plan.